Legendary Oxtail Soup
Recipe by Sandra Djohan4
servings30
minutes4
hoursKeep the screen of your device on
Ingredients
- Oxtail, Broth, and Vegetables
1 kg oxtail, cut into sections, preferably meaty center cuts
2.5–3 liters water for the broth, plus extra for blanching the oxtail and boiling the potatoes
500 g carrots, peeled and cut diagonally into 2–3 cm thick pieces
2–3 potatoes, peeled and cut into roughly 3 cm cubes
2 scallions, cut into 4–5 cm lengths
2 celery stalks, tied together
1 tbsp neutral oil, divided between searing the oxtail and sautéing the aromatics
1 tsp fine salt, plus more to taste
½ tsp granulated sugar, or to taste
½ tsp mushroom bouillon powder or other seasoning powder, optional
- Aromatics and whole spices
8 garlic cloves, lightly crushed
4–5 shallots, lightly crushed
1 onion, quartered
1 piece fresh ginger, about 10 cm long, thinly sliced and lightly bruised
½ whole nutmeg, cracked into 2–3 large pieces
5 cardamom pods, lightly crushed to split the husks
1 cinnamon stick, about 5 cm long
5 whole cloves
2 whole star anise
- Sambal kecap and accompaniments
4 tbsp kecap manis (Indonesian sweet soy sauce)
6–10 bird’s-eye chilies, thinly sliced
3 shallots, thinly sliced
1–2 limes, cut into wedges
Crispy fried shallots, for topping
Emping melinjo (melinjo crackers), for serving
Warm steamed white rice, optional
Directions
- Blanch the oxtail for 5 minutes
Bring enough water to a boil to cover the oxtail. Add the pieces, wait for the water to return to a boil, then blanch for 5 minutes. Lift the oxtail out with tongs and discard the blanching water.
Dip the pieces in a bowl of clean water and gently rub away any clinging foam. Drain, then pat the pieces thoroughly dry with paper towels. Clean the pot and dry the bottom before using it again. - Brown one side of each oxtail piece
Heat 2 tsp oil in the pot over medium-high heat. Arrange the oxtail in a single layer, working in two batches if the pot is crowded. Place the broadest meaty side down and sear undisturbed for 2–3 minutes, until golden and easy to lift from the pot.
Transfer the oxtail to a plate. Browning one side gives the broth a lightly roasted flavor and keeps its clear golden color. Leave the golden bits in the pot. If any bits have burned, wipe them away with a paper towel held in the tongs. - Sauté the aromatics and deglaze the pot
Reduce the heat to medium. Add the remaining 1 tsp oil if the bottom of the pot is dry. Sauté the onion and ginger for 2–3 minutes, until the edges of the onion begin to turn translucent. Add the shallots and garlic and stir for 1–2 minutes, until fragrant.
Add the nutmeg, cardamom, cinnamon, cloves, and star anise. Stir for 20–30 seconds. Pour in about 200 ml of the measured broth water and scrape the bottom with a wooden spatula until the golden bits dissolve. If you have a spice bag, transfer the whole spices to it and return it to the pot so you can lift them out easily later. - Slow-braise the oxtail for 2½–3½ hours
Return the oxtail and any juices from the plate to the pot. Pour in enough water to bring the total to 2.5 liters, including the water used to deglaze. Use more of the measured water if needed to cover the oxtail by about 2–3 cm.
Heat gradually over medium heat. Skim off any foam with a ladle. When small bubbles begin to appear around the edges, reduce the heat and add 1 tsp salt. Set the lid slightly ajar, leaving a 1–2 cm gap, and start timing.
• During the first 20 minutes, skim away any foam that rises. Keep the broth at a gentle simmer, with an occasional small bubble breaking at the edge. If using a thermometer, aim for 85–95°C and keep the surface mostly still.
• After 45 minutes, taste the broth. Remove the spice bag when the spices are clearly fragrant and the beef flavor still leads, usually after 45–60 minutes. If the spices are loose and difficult to fish out, temporarily lift out the oxtail, strain the broth, then return both to the pot.
• Every 30–45 minutes, check the liquid level. If the tops of the oxtail pieces begin to emerge, add hot water 100–150 ml at a time until they are submerged again.
• After 2½ hours, test the thickest piece. Insert a fork into the meat close to the bone. The oxtail is ready when the fork slides in with little resistance and the meat begins to pull away from the bone with a gentle twist. If it is still chewy, continue cooking and check again every 20 minutes. - Cook the potatoes separately
When the oxtail is nearly tender, put the potatoes in a small saucepan with cold water and a little salt. Bring to a gentle boil and cook for 10–15 minutes, depending on the size of the cubes. Drain when the tip of a knife slides through the center and the corners still hold their shape. Cooking the potatoes separately keeps their starch from clouding the broth. - Strain the broth, adjust its concentration, and cook the carrots
Lift out the oxtail with tongs and keep it covered. Strain the broth through a fine-mesh strainer into a clean pot. Let it drain on its own, leaving the aromatics in the strainer. Let the broth settle briefly, then skim off the fat that collects on the surface. Leave a little for flavor.
Taste the broth before adding more salt. If the beef flavor is light, simmer uncovered over medium-low heat for 10–15 minutes, then taste again. Add the carrots and celery. Simmer gently for 12–18 minutes, until the carrots can be pierced easily and still hold their shape. Remove the celery.
Return the oxtail to the broth and add the scallions. Heat gently for 2–3 minutes. Add ½ tsp sugar, the mushroom bouillon if using, and a little salt at a time until the beef flavor comes through fully. - Make the sambal kecap and serve
Stir the sliced chilies and shallots into the kecap manis. Add a squeeze of lime if you like, then let the sambal stand for 5 minutes.
Divide the potatoes, carrots, and oxtail among warmed bowls. Ladle over the hot broth and scatter with crispy fried shallots just before serving. Serve with emping melinjo, sambal kecap, and lime wedges, and squeeze lime into each bowl to taste.
Chef Sandra’s Note
- If the oxtail is tender and the broth still tastes light, lift out the oxtail first, then reduce the broth. This deepens the beef flavor and keeps the oxtail pieces intact for serving.
From My Kitchen to Yours
Sandra Djohan
Sop Buntut Troubleshooting
Problem | Likely cause | How to fix it |
The oxtail is still tough after 3 hours | Thick center cuts take longer for the connective tissue around the bone to soften. | Simmer gently for another 20 minutes, then test the thickest piece with a fork close to the bone. The meat should begin to pull away with a gentle twist. Add enough hot water to cover any exposed pieces. |
The broth looks cloudy | A rolling boil mixed the foam back into the broth, or the potatoes released starch into the soup. | Reduce the heat, remove the oxtail, and let the broth settle for a few minutes. Skim the surface, then slowly pour the broth through a fine-mesh strainer lined with clean cheesecloth, leaving the sediment behind. This can improve clarity, though starch or emulsified fat may leave some cloudiness. |
The broth tastes thin or lacks beef flavor | There is too much water, or the oxtail needs more time. | If the meat is still tough, keep simmering gently. Once it is tender, remove it and keep it covered. Simmer the broth uncovered for 10–15 minutes, then taste. Repeat if needed and adjust the salt once the broth is concentrated enough. |
The broth is too greasy | The oxtail released a lot of fat, especially from the thicker pieces. | Turn off the heat and let the broth stand for 5 minutes. Tilt a ladle just below the surface to skim off the pooled fat. Leave a little for flavor. |
The nutmeg, cloves, or star anise overpower the broth | The whole spices steeped too long. | Remove the spices or strain the broth right away. If the spice flavor is still too strong, gradually add 100–150 ml unsalted beef stock, tasting as you go. Next time, start tasting at 45 minutes and lift out the spices as soon as the broth is fragrant enough. |
The broth tastes bitter or smells burnt | The aromatics, spices, or browned bits scorched. | Transfer the broth and oxtail to a clean pot without scraping the bottom. Strain and taste. A little unsalted stock can soften mild bitterness. If the burnt flavor has spread throughout the broth, replace it with fresh stock and reheat the oxtail in it. |
The broth is too salty after reducing | The salt was added before the broth reached its final volume. | Add hot water or unsalted beef stock 100 ml at a time, stirring and tasting after each addition. Once the flavor is balanced, warm gently and serve before the broth reduces further. |
The carrots are mushy or the potatoes are falling apart | The vegetables cooked too long or were reheated repeatedly in the broth. | Lift out any pieces that are still intact. If needed, cook fresh carrots in the strained broth until a knife slides in with a little resistance. Boil a fresh batch of potatoes separately and place them directly in the serving bowls. |